Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Cathie Campbell's avatar

Wow! Just Wow!

Expand full comment
Christoph Mussenbrock's avatar

Nicely written - . But it somehow feels like a sad story.

You suggest that once humanity leaves Earth behind, the problems caused by “bureaucrats, prophets of decline, and beggars” disappear. But history shows that wherever people go, they bring their conflicts, their systems of power, and their blind spots with them. If paradise was “lost to corruption” once, why wouldn’t it be lost again on Mars, or the Belt, or beyond?

IMO escapism, whether through technology, colonization, or immortality, can delay problems but rarely solves them. It risks turning our attention away from the harder, more uncomfortable task: learning to build good societies where we are (however you define "good" - that's the problem - there's always a plurality of ideas what that means!). Otherwise, the old fractures reappear under new skies, only more dangerous, because now they stretch across planets or across centuries.

The danger, I think, is twofold:

1. Neglect of responsibility. If we believe salvation lies in flight, we may abandon the responsibility to repair what is broken here and now.

2. Repetition of cycles. Without deep transformation, ethical, social, and political, our “escape” becomes nothing more than exporting our unsolved problems into new frontiers.

Progress and exploration are vital, yes. But unless they are coupled with self-criticism and moral growth, they become another form of denial. Real greatness, it seems to me, isn’t in refusing decay, but in facing it, mending what can be mended, and creating anew without forgetting what was lost.

Expand full comment

No posts

Ready for more?