#126 – Why Price Controls Cannot Work
Price controls, whether setting maximum or minimum prices, disrupt the natural functioning of the market. Prices are signals that convey crucial information about supply and demand. When the state interferes, these signals become distorted, leading to inefficiencies.
Price ceilings (e.g., rent controls) create shortages by discouraging suppliers from providing the good or service. When prices are kept artificially low, the incentive to produce or maintain the supply diminishes, leading to scarcity.
Price floors, like minimum wage laws, lead to surpluses—unemployment in this case. When wages are set above the market rate, employers hire fewer workers, as the cost of labor exceeds the value it can generate.
The fundamental flaw of price controls is the assumption that prices are merely numbers that can be adjusted without consequence. In reality, prices are emergent outcomes of countless individual decisions, reflecting subjective valuations and opportunity costs.
Interfering with prices is akin to silencing the market’s voice. Entrepreneurs can no longer accurately assess consumer desires or the availability of resources, leading to misallocation and waste.
Ultimately, price controls aim to achieve short-term goals (e.g., affordable housing, higher wages) but at the cost of long-term economic health. They destroy the very mechanisms—market signals, competition, entrepreneurship—that drive prosperity.
The market, left to its own devices, better allocates resources according to the needs and preferences of individuals. Price controls, by contrast, lead to unintended consequences that harm both consumers and producers.
The lesson is clear: prices are not arbitrary numbers to be dictated by authority. They are vital to the functioning of the economy, ensuring that scarce resources are used where they are most valued.
P.S. I’m hiring a video editor to work with me on an exciting project. Reply to this email or DM me on X with some proof of work if you’re interested. While it isn’t a requirement, it helps if you’re interested in similar ideas as I am :)
Follow me on X: @arjunkhemani
Click here to support my work.
> prices are emergent outcomes of countless individual decisions, reflecting subjective valuations and opportunity costs.
Austrians are ambiguous about subjectivity as split from reality or as mans power to know reality. And, I believe, valuations include opportunity costs. The basic fact is that markets transform values, ie, actions to keep or get something, into prices.
> > natural functioning of the market
Markets are the product of the minds knowledge of reality, not of nature alone, not biology or physics. When mind communicates with mind via a market, there are definite effects (hated by the haters of independent minds). The Enlightenment created our market culture.
For more on values and markets:
What Is Capitalism-Ayn Rand, online
Economic Theory And Conceptions Of Value-Rob Tarr, in Foundations Of A Free Society-G. ....Salmieri
The fact that price controls disrupt the natural functioning of the market is irrelevant , because markets don't exist to be markets, they exist to serve human needs.